Placing a Web Order

When you see an item you like, click on the "Add to Cart" icon and continue shopping until you are ready to complete your purchase. Then, click the “Cart” icon, located at the top of the screen. Click "View All" to confirm your items. After you have made any changes and updated the quantities as desired, click on "Proceed to Checkout" to finish. Please review your order carefully before placing it. Once your order is submitted, we are unable to modify it.

• Visa
• Mastercard
• Paypal
• Magic Pony Gift Card

Please note: You will only be charged when you have clicked "Confirm" during Checkout. You will be charged ONLY for the items that you have purchased, along with the applicable shipping and tax charges. 

We are required to collect sales tax for deliveries to all provinces and territories in Canada. The tax rate applied to your order will generally be the local rate for the address where your order is shipped. We are required by law to collect tax on shipping charges where applicable.

Once you place your order, you will be given an order number. You will also receive a confirmation email with an order summary.


You can check the status of your order by clicking on "Log In" or "Account" in the top navigation bar. Once you have logged in, select "My Orders" from the left side navigation. Once you've found your order, click on the order number to view the details. If the order has shipped, click on the tracking number to track the status of your package. 


All prices and other amounts appearing on the site are quoted in CAD. Prices are subject to change without notice. Purchase prices are final at the date of purchase. 


We are a small, independent company and truly appreciate your order. We do our best to offer great artist-created products with helpful, responsive customer service. We have developed what we believe is a fair return policy as stated below; please note that by purchasing goods from Magic Pony, you have agreed to the following terms:


Magic Pony wants you to love your stuff! If you bought a product online that wasn’t what you expected, you have 15 days since date of delivery to either exchange it or receive a store credit for the total amount paid discounting shipping costs (shipping costs are non-refundable). The product must be in its original condition. We do not offer refunds but we will try our best to exchange it with something else that you like. Magic Pony will not accept returns or exchanges on items purchased from any other stores. Items damaged due to customer abuse or negligence will not be accepted.

Please note that all discounted merchandise on sale is FINAL SALE.


Please use one of the following methods to return your order:


Prior to shipping your returned purchase, please contact our Web Sales department at 416-861-1684 or within 15 days from the date of delivery, for further instructions. We regret that we do not reimburse shipping costs. 


Most of the figures we sell are collectible, made in limited runs and are often hand-painted or assembled. Slight imperfections are typical with this kind of product and most often enhance the value. However, if your merchandise has a significant defect right out of the box (e.g. the product is broken or missing parts, etc.), we’ll be happy to exchange it for a non-damaged item within 7 days of purchase. All other toy sales at are final. 

Please contact our Web Sales department at 416-861-1684 or within 
 from the date of receipt. Provide images of the defective product with your name, email address and receipt number. Please note: Magic Pony will only accept defective returns for items that are received in their original packaging. Blister cards, accessories, plastic packaging, and anything else that came with the item must be included as well. If your return does not meet these conditions, you’ll be charged a 15% re-stocking fee or have your defective merchandise returned to you. Items damaged due to customer abuse or negligence will not be accepted. 


Any product bag or piece of apparel suffering from a manufacturing defect may be returned or exchanged within three months of the date of purchase. "Defects" are mistakes in the manufacturing process and do not include damage from normal wear and tear or negligent usage. Magic Pony will determine the validity of manufacturing defect returns on a case-by-case basis. Email photos of the defective product to with your name, phone number and invoice reference number. 

Thanks again for shopping with Magic Pony!